Category Archives: Uncategorized

Recent Coverage Roundup

While many of our posts are tweeted and blogged about, our recent post on Nick Fury and Illegal Orders has attracted more attention than usual, so we thought we’d give a shout out to people and sites that have written about us recently.  The illegal orders post was republished in its entirety on io9, and linked on Whedonesque, Dr. Sputnik’s Society Pages (a blog related to nndb.com), Nodwick (you can expect a post on related comic PS238 soon), and Diane Duane‘s tumblr.

Our other Avengers-related posts were also written about at blogs like The Mary Sue, A Very Nice Website, the Administrative Law Prof Blog, Wired’s Geek Dad blog, and Alyssa Rosenberg’s blog at Thinkprogress.

Adam Chodorow’s guest post about Death and Taxes and Zombies (and the related full-length article) naturally caught the attention of the internet with write-ups and discussion at io9, MetaFilter, and Neatorama.

Our most recent Subculture for the Cultured column, Daredevil and International Law, received praise from Christopher Borgen, a professor and associate dean at St. John’s University School of Law and co-founder of Opinio Juris, an international law blog.

The Uniques: Overview

Last month, I (Ryan) had the privilege of presenting at Summit City Comic Con. While there, I had the good fortune to meet Comfort Love and Adam Withers, the married-couple creators of The Uniques. Comfort and Adam are independent comic creators, and by “independent,” I don’t mean “publishing for someone other than Marvel or DC,” I mean “promoting their work at the con circuit and self-publishing with print on demand.” Comics are their full-time job, and if you’ve run across them at a con, odds are you’ve seen their delightful presentation, “Creating Your Comic From Concept to Publication.” Turns out self-publishing as a full-time job, which is what they do, is at least as much “running a small business” as it is drawing and writing.

Their main work thus far is, as mentioned, The Uniques. They’ve got nine issues out so far, available individually in either hard copy or a variety of digital formats, in trade paperbacks, or my preferred edition, Vol. I of the omnibus, which has all nine issues. You have to buy directly from them, which in a sense is surprising, because if the big guys were writing stories this good they might not be seeing the sales slump they’ve complained of for the past decade or so.

And make no mistake: The Uniques is good. I had dinner with Comfort and Adam after the con, and they explained it this way: The Uniques is an exploration of a world in which superheroes are real in the way that the Marvel [amazon_link id=”0785121781″ target=”_blank” container=”” container_class=”” ]Civil War[/amazon_link] should have been but wasn’t. A lot of comics are basically magical realism. Fantastic stuff happens, but the world at large just sort of goes on the way it always has. This despite the fact that the mere existence of something like telepathy would have enormous implications for daily life. The Uniques is set in a world where those implications are real. Humanity is now made up of “uniques,” people with supernormal powers, and “typics,” people without them. The background history is still being revealed, but thus far we know that the first uniques showed up in 1939. They fought in World War II on both sides, but the outcome of the war was largely the same. Virtue, the first unique to appear, delivered the bombs over Hiroshima and Nagasaki, for example, but the bombs were still delivered. The rest of the century unfolded more-or-less as we know it–Vietnam happened, with uniques again participating on both sides–but the presence of uniques added a level of tension to the Cold War that was lacking in the history we know. The Soviet Union apparently didn’t dissolve in the late 1980s, and things were coming to a head in 1993 when a team of uniques from both sides of the conflict joined forces to put an end to the Cold War. How hasn’t been revealed yet, but there are hints that this is going to be central to the larger plot. Regardless, uniques are a recognized part of society, and as the story unfolds, we’re seeing how legal and administrative structures have evolved to deal with them.

Only we’re seeing it without a writer’s revolt that led to Iron Man acting like a complete jerk for about two years, and Mr. Fantastic finally abandoning his normal uselessness to create a seriously evil system of incarceration. Heck, we’re seeing a society that actually makes use of uniques and the technology that goes along with them. But more than that, the pro-reg forces in Civil War were supposed to have the better part of the argument. Unfortunately, any message, pro- or anti-reg, was completely lost in the ensuing soap opera, inconsistent conception of the core laws at issue, and what seem to have been political disagreements amongst the writing staff. Remember, Civil War came out at the height of the Second Gulf War, and the media was still full of stories debating the merits of the war and the US’s continued detention of alleged “enemy combatants” in Guantanamo Bay. Some of those issues continue to be pressing, but there may have been enough time between then and now to permit a more detached, less immediately political discussion about related issues. The world of The Uniques assumes that there is some compromise to be made between security and liberty, just as a practical matter, and some of the characters are significantly motivated by their attempts to figure out where they fit in that compromise. Marvel, on the other hand, seems to have been surprised by the idea that any kind of compromise is even warranted, much less appropriate, and the whole thing is somewhere between a dork age, canon discontinuity, and downright negative continuity.

So over the next few weeks, we’re going to be taking a look at the Uniques, seeing how Comfort and Adam are creating what may fairly be called the most robust venture into a world that takes superheroes and supervillians both seriously and in stride.

Any Military Lawyers in the House?

We recently got a great question from a reader about The Avengers that involves the law of war, the UCMJ, and illegal orders.  That’s pretty far afield for us, and we don’t have a ton of research sources in that area.  Are there any military lawyers out there who might like to give us a hand with a post on it?  If so, send me an email!

Administrative News

In this case that means site administration, not administrative law.  We recently switched hosting providers in order to enable some new site features in the future, and that has a couple of side-effects.  First, the site may have been unavailable for a brief period during the switchover.  If you had trouble accessing the site recently, that’s why.  Second, some of the little avatar icons may change.  I know mine did, but rest assured it’s actually me and not some mustachioed evil twin.  Apart from that, everything should work the same as it always has.  If not, please let us know in the comments or by email.

Batman, Vigilantism, and the State

We here at Law and the Multiverse generally try to avoid policy discussions implicated by superheros and comic book stories generally, but there’s a really interesting conversation about the role of Batman in civil society and his usurpation on the state’s monopoly on violence going on right now.

Taylor Martin kicks things off over at Prospect Blog, suggesting

The Dark Knight’s central thesis is that social norms don’t break down in the absence of governmentally-imposed order. But this isn’t a happy revelation. The fact that one man can demolish governmental authority in Gotham and strain social order to the breaking point illustrates just how illusionary the foundation of order society — and our comfortable lives — rest on actually is.

Erik Kain counters over at Forbes, arguing

The central thesis, as I see it, is that Batman would be unnecessary if good people not wearing masks would actually stand up and recapture their own self-determination. A vigilante is not necessary for this at all. Batman is the option of last resort.

Jamelle Bouie continues, disagreeing with Marvin’s assessment of Bruce Wayne’s motivations:

Bruce wants a better Gotham, which is why he’s willing to endure the hatred of his home if that’s what it takes to build the city into something durable.

Ethan Gache at The League of Ordinary Gentlemen doubles down, saying

[F]or several reasons I think there’s a compelling case to be made for situating Batman not only within civil society, but as the fullest expression of it. The principle of handing over one’s individual claim to violence to the state, when taken to its logical conclusion, results in a police state. And that is in many ways what Batman symbolizes: a regime in which decisions are made unilaterally and enforced to their fullest extent.

Alyssa Rosenberg at Think Progress asks, on a parallel note, if maybe it isn’t worth looking more broadly at the “radicalization of elites” generally, drawing a comparison to Downton Abbey.

Again, this isn’t a strictly legal discussion, but it’s a great discussion about some of the core questions that superheroes in general and Batman in particular wrestle with a lot of the time. Don’t miss it.

Year One Giveaway Winners!

Congratulations to the winners of our Law and the Multiverse: Year One giveaway!  Our winners are:

Tom Wilder
Chris Amico
Walter Biggart
Jack Flynn
Pat Gunn

Each of them has won a copy of Batman: Year One!  We will contact the winners shortly to arrange shipping.  Thanks to everyone who entered and all the well wishes we received as well.  We’re looking forward to another great year!

The 2011 ABA Journal Blawg 100

Law and the Multiverse has been selected for the American Bar Association Journal’s 2011 Blawg 100! Thanks to everyone who nominated us!  We invite our readers to register to vote for the best blog in each category.  Registration is free and doubles as registration for ABAJournal.com.  Unlike the nomination phase, we believe voting for the top blogs is open to everyone.  Voting ends on December 30.  You can find Law and the Multiverse under the “For Fun” category, but please check out the other great blogs in the list; we read some of them every day!

Law and the Multiverse: Year One

It’s hard to believe, but today marks the first anniversary of Law and the Multiverse, as measured by its public debut on MetaFilter Projects.  Since then we’ve been featured all over the web and been interviewed in print and on the radio in multiple countries (look for an interview with us on the German legal news website Legal Tribune Online coming soon).  We’ve already mentioned it in interviews, but we’re also happy to announce here on the blog that we have a book coming out next summer from Gotham Books, a division of Penguin.  (The names are a coincidence, but we think it’s hilarious anyway.)  We’re very excited about the book and hope to meet many of you at comic book conventions next year.

And speaking of our readers, we’d like to take this opportunity to thank you.  Your support has been fantastic, and your questions, comments, and post ideas are a big part of what makes this blog special.  To celebrate, we’re giving away five copies of the critically acclaimed series Batman: Year One!  To enter, simply send an email with “Law and the Multiverse Anniversary Giveaway” in the subject to lawandthemultiversegiveaway@gmail.com.  International entries are welcome.  Please note that you must be 13 or older to enter.  One entry per person.  Void where prohibited.  We’ll choose the winners at random from among all of the entries we receive and announce them on Friday, December 9th, 2011.  Don’t worry about including your address in the entry; we’ll contact the winners for shipping information.  And of course, your contact information will only be used for conducting the giveaway.

Another Poll!

Since we started Law and the Multiverse we’ve gotten a lot of questions about non-comic-book-based movies, TV shows, and books, and on the heels of our posts about Castle we’ve seen an uptick in the number of those questions.  While we try to keep the blog focused on comic books, superheroes, and broadly-related media, it’s clear that there’s an interest in discussing how the law works (or doesn’t!) in other kinds of fiction.  So to gauge that interest among our readers we’ve set up a poll.  If enough people are keen on the idea, then we’ll start a sister-site with a wider scope.  Let us know what you think!

[polldaddy poll=5594579]

Mark Waid Interview at Abnormal Use

Jim Dedman over at Abnormal Use just posted a great interview with Mark Waid, the writer of Daredevil.  You may remember Jim and Abnormal Use from the interview with us back in March.  And speaking of Daredevil, we’ll be covering issue 3 tomorrow and issue 4 next week.  Waid continues to do a great job writing the book, and there are some really interesting legal issues to discuss, so check back soon!